Government Watch / Politics

Mississippi – Is Appointing Judges Racist?

A strange twist is afoot in Mississippi, and it represents the modern tendency to accuse first, shout racism, examine facts later. Getting to truth is worth the time, closely looking at facts before pushing easy narratives, hate, riots, and “Jim Crow” accusations.

In short, the capitol city of Mississippi is Jackson, as Washington DC is America’s capitol. The city has roughly 150,000 residents, 80 percent black, 15 percent white, five percent other.

A law is under consideration – passed in the House – to shift part of Jackson’s judicial and prosecutorial makeup from elected to appointed officers. The appointments would come from the Supreme Court.

Because the city district affected is demographically more white than black – the argument is that “appointing” is racist, or likely to produce more white judges. A certain irony attaches to this argument, since if all judges were elected by district, elections might produce more white judges here.

But let’s dig deeper. What is really happening in Jackson? What makes it different – might otherwise explain changing the system? For starters, high crime. Jackson’s crime rate is double the national average, triple Mississippi’s average, especially murder, rape, robbery, and assault.

That spike follows the devastating 2020 race riots, led by “Black Lives Matter.” Those riots were violent, spawned post-riot violence. In 2020, Jackson recorded the highest number of murders in the city’s history, more killing than New Orleans or Memphis.

The aftershocks were measurable, obvious. Police morale plummeted, recruiting and retention fell through the floor, population insecure. This reinforced crime, and attacks on the police, as well as disaffection for prosecutors, judges, and pro “rule of law” political actors.

Ironically, the top six officers in the Jackson Police Command Staff are black, chief, assistant, and four deputies. More to the point, legislators of every stripe, black and white, Democrat and Republican know “rule of law” is tenuous.

As one black Democrat legislator bluntly notes: “We are not going to prosper in Jackson if there’s not rule of law in place… We’re losing businesses … family.. Anyone who can get out of Jackson right now is largely getting out. I believe that we’ve got to do something differently from what we’ve been doing.”

He is not wrong. Even before the recent exodus, rise of fear, decline of police, accelerating crime, Jackson was hemorrhaging residents. In fact, Jackson lost more residents between 2010 and 2020 than any city in America. If you want shock – that is shock.

As Republicans – who control the legislature, sitting in Jackson – and some Democrats, struggle with these numbers and look for solutions, one has been to focus resources and try new ideas, including a turn to appointed judges and prosecutors – instead of elected, for this Jackson district.

Will it work? Is this the right place to begin? Is appointing judges – by the Supreme Court – racist? That is yet to be determined, but is there a problem? Yes.

Putting aside the specifics of Jackson, how are judges traditionally chosen – in Mississippi and America? Answer is, elected and appointed, with appointments by various means, legislature, governor, court.

In Mississippi, the tradition exists to have all judges elected. While this is not necessarily more insulated from politics – indeed, one could argue elections are more political than appointments – it has been the practice.

The real problem now is that what has been used is not working, as candid Democrats know. So, what is to be done? If elected judges and prosecutors are not producing “rule of law,” what is left?

In Jackson – and across the country – as “rule of law” is put in jeopardy by anti “rule of law” violence, ambushes and shootings of police, low morale, recruitment and retention, other ideas are surfacing.  Appointing judges and prosecutors is one – for Jackson, Mississippi.

Bottom line: Jackson, Mississippi is in a state of social, political, legal, and demographic jeopardy. What has been tried – is failing, miserably. People know it. A turn to appointing judges and prosecutors, whether for one district or an entire city may be a reasonable step toward reclaiming public safety.

The problem really is that unhappiness with social, political, and legal circumstances – anywhere at any time for any reason – too often turns into finger pointing, blame casting, and mutual recrimination. Admiring the problem, blaming it on someone else, crying racism is easier than fixing it.

In Jackson, and across the nation, the most urgent problem facing America is probably not racism, but something simpler. Political actors and the media have decided blaming others is the way to go. Late bulletin: That road leads down. The high road leads up. Talk facts, use logic. Judicial appointments may work. Trying them is not inherently racist. Defaulting to racist cross-allegations gets us nowhere.

Robert Charles is a former Assistant Secretary of State under Colin Powell, former Reagan and Bush 41 White House staffer, attorney, and naval intelligence officer (USNR). He wrote “Narcotics and Terrorism” (2003), “Eagles and Evergreens” (2018), and is National Spokesman for AMAC.

We hope you've enjoyed this article. While you're here, we have a small favor to ask...

Support AMAC Action. Our 501 (C)(4) advances initiatives on Capitol Hill, in the state legislatures, and at the local level to protect American values, free speech, the exercise of religion, equality of opportunity, sanctity of life, and the rule of law.

Donate Now

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter
and Download the AMAC App

Sign Up Today Download

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter!

Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David Millikan
2 months ago

There is nothing racist about the Mississippi state flag. It is part of American history that should not be lost since it represents two sides joined as one to become a State in the United States of America.
Besides, racist is a word created by democrats who are the true racist.

Dan W.
2 months ago
Reply to  David Millikan

That symbol of the ‘Lost Cause’ belongs in museums or in history books, not on the public square.

Ask your Black acquaintances how they feel about the battle flag of northern Virginia and then come back and tell us why that symbol belonged on any state flag.

Lieutenant Beale
2 months ago
Reply to  Dan W.

Apparently H. K. Edgerton and the late Anthony Hervey don’t have a problem with that flag.

Dan W.
2 months ago

Neither does the Klan. That battle flag is their favorite banner.

Lieutenant Beale
2 months ago
Reply to  Dan W.

Google the klan march in Washington DC. I don’t see too many Confederate flags in those photos señor. Quit reading so called history books by Eric Foner or Howard Zinn (both hard leftists and/or socialists) And no, I am not from the South. I was born in New York City and grew up in Southern California.

Dan W.
2 months ago

How many Confederate battle flags is too many ?

I grew up in Indiana so I’m not from the South either but I spent the first 20 years of my working life in Georgia.

I pose the same challenge to you as I did to Millikan.

Ask your Black acquaintances how they feel about the battle flag of northern Virginia. That would give you a more reliable indicator of the battle flag’s effect than the opinions two black guys that you’ve read about.

2 months ago

Oh, so not Southern…just a racist! Got it!

23 days ago
Reply to  EllyC

My, oh, my what a giant leap that statement is, not to mention childish.

23 days ago
Reply to  Dan W.

The Klan, otherwise known as the democrat party?

Dan W.
2 months ago

Note to AMAC editors: The old Mississippi state flag that you display at the beginning of this article ceased to be the Mississippi state flag over two years ago. The State of Mississippi no longer embeds the battle flag of the army of northern Virginia anywhere on the Mississippi state flag.

Since this article is about racism, I’m surprised that the author didn’t notice this error.

2 months ago
Reply to  Dan W.

Good thought, observation, and correction! Thank you!

2 months ago

The word “Racist” has been used by the left so much, it no longer has any real meaning. Add to that, everything they blame the Right for, is what they are and are actually doing. Jim Crow was the Demorat’s, as was slavery and everything Racist. They only accept what they themselves want, which in itself is racist. Let them cry, whine and pout and when they “peacefully protest” – this time, convince them it’s a bad idea by any means required to shut them up and control their temper tantrums. I am just totally sick of their whining. If this country is so bad, they can leave and see how great it is somewhere else.

anna hubert
2 months ago

So much crime so little outrage from the media

2 months ago

Uh, the problem is obvious but there are strong social prohibitions against speaking it openly. So we’ll continue dancing around it hoping for some magical evolutionary advancement. Meanwhile vast urban areas will be turned into no mans land and cries for more federal money will echo in the hallowed halls of government.

Kyle Buy you some guns,and learn how to shoot
2 months ago

Things wont change until blacks go after blacks, andbvquit voting democratic. Kyle L.

Stephen Russell
2 months ago

Being home of the KKK makes sense

2 months ago


Informative article. The way I see it, the non-stop drumbeat of shouting racism as a dog whistle for virtually everything the left objects to or seeks to vilify, by the Democrat politicians and the MSM, has created an automatic response from the Democrat voter base. Everything is subject to condemnation, if anything runs counter to the socialist ideology being pumped out 24×7 by the mouthpieces of the left. So sure, law and order will suffer. Crime will of course rise in direct correlation to the decline in law enforcement and the vilification of those whose job is to enforce the laws and protect the public.

As society becomes dumber and dumber and acts more like an ignorant mob carrying torches and pitchforks everytime someone shouts the dog whistle of racism, those trying to stem the tide of decline will encounter pushback.

Whether the move to appoint, rather than elect judges in this specific case moves forward, the underlying issue is the electorate is becoming dumber and dumber and more easily manipulated by the left which seeks to undermine the country as a whole. How we opt to address that issue, if we choose to publicly address it at all, will determine how successful any such proposed point solution will be. Again, a very informative article.

2 months ago
Reply to  PaulE

RBC, nail hit directly on the head. The issues are also that democrats are weak on crime prevention because they refuse to prosecute those who have broken the law, including BLM and ANTIFA thugs that are anything but democratic and fascist at their core. Any group that would promote force and riot over peaceful demonstration needs to reevaluate their reality of confess their actual truth, which they did, then took it off their website.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x